Offered Westy and Mason for my Mendy and Walter..WHIR

[SameSongNDance]

I get..

Brian Westbrook and Mason

I give up..

Mendenhall and K. Walter

This is a PPR league so a healthy Westbrook and Mason > Mendenhall and Walter. The problem is, Westbrook hasn't managed to stay healthy all year. I am really debating pulling the trigger. Mendenhall is on a bye anyway...leave a link.

[across777]

Depends on if you need the WR (Mason).

Mendenhall is much more valuable than Westbrook. Mendenhall has been better so far, and no reason to think he won't continue. Westbrook has already had 2 injuries, the rookie McCoy is getting lots of looks (they are almost a time-share already), and the no Eagle RB has really done anything all year because the team is running even less than usual.

Also if you don't have McCoy or you can't get him cheaply, then you're setting yourself up for a tough situation.

So personally I think you're giving up a very good RB, so I'd only even consider this is you are really hurting at WR and need Mason.

[JaysFan]

I wouldn't do this. Westbrook is more injury prone than usual, AND THAT IS SAYING SOMETHING. I like Mason but I think Walter could erupt in that offence. Don't do it.

Help with mine??? viewtopic.php?t=458549