Super important trade question!!!! WHIR ALWAYS!!!! HELP!!!!!

[bostonsoxandy]

Some person in my league offered both of these trades to me

TRADE ONE: I give up Hakeem Nicks for Brett Favre and Felix Jones
TRADE TWO: I give up Hakeem Nicks for Brett Favre and Austin Collie

My team now
QB Matt Ryan
RB Steven Jackson
RB Ronnie Brown
RB/WR Ray Rice
WR Roddy White
WR Jerricho Cotchery
WR Hakeem Nicks
TE Tony Gonzalez
D/ST Vikigns
K Scobee

BE Steve Breaston
BE Beanie Wells
BE Terrell Owens
BE Laveranues Coles


I think I need a backup QB and Matt Ryan has been iffy and Favre is number 7 or 8 overall at QB in my league while Matt Ryan is 15. I would prolly switch them in and out.

IT IS A 1 POINT PPR LEAGUE

Please let me know if I should take one of those trades, why, or why not. and whcih one. thanks
WHIR
andy

[JrcWy]

Do it and take Collie. Nicks isnt going to grossly outperform Breaston and who know what the switch to Fitzpatrick in Buffolo will do to TO (he can only go up). Farve gives you an alternative each week to White although i hate Farve with a passion.

http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=458527

[drew1265]

i would give up nicks for farve and collie, collie is clearly ahead of garcon at this point and nicks is going to be sharing looks with manningham and hixon, do the deal

help me viewtopic.php?f=18&t=458521

[bassackwards]

I agree with the others....do the deal and take Favre and Collie!

[JaysFan]

Collie could be better than Nicks and Favre could be huge. Do this deal.

Help with mine??? viewtopic.php?t=458549

[bostonsoxandy]

Collie could be better than Nicks and Favre could be huge. Do this deal.

Help with mine??? viewtopic.php?t=458549

I took the trade guys!!!!!!! Hopefuly it will pan out. BTW my team is 5-2 right now, and only 4 people don't make the playoffs so I'm good for the playoffs prolyl

Will answer all the links in a second...
But new question-
Do I start
Matt Ryan @ New Orleans
or
Brett Favre @ Green Bay
Leaning towards Favre....let me know what you would do though. Bonus to 300 plus yard games as well. 6 pt/TD

[MadDog36]

Brett Favre and Felix Jones or Collie work. I like Felix though.

[RBManiac]

you had matt ryan already.

now you have to basically depend on collie with gonzalez coming back to put up numbers.

Nicks will out perform collie and breaston on any given day