Grant/Sims-Walker for Brown/Walter? WHIR

[Carnac]

I just put up a trade to upgrade RB. I give Ryan Grant and Mike Sims-Walker for Ronnie Brown and Kevin Walter.

I like Brown's schedule going forward. What do you think?

My team

QB Rodgers, Flacco
RB DeAngelo, Rice, Grant, Hightower, Charles
WR Moss, Harvin, Sims-Walker, Collie, Ginn Jr. (we count return yards)
TE Celek
K Akers
D Green Bay

His team

QB Schaub, Ryan
RB Forte, C. Johnson, Gore, Brown
WR Ocho, Marshall, Bryant, Walter
TE Shiancoe, Watson
K Tynes
D Chicago, Seattle

I get upgrade at RB and he gets his upgrade at WR. He was shopping Brown for a WR.

[Hags888]

Seems even to me, I'd make the trade.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=459243

[soty]

I like Brown a little more than Grant, but Walker for Walter is the deal breaker for me. I am not too big of a Walter fan and Walker has produced week in and week out. I personally would stand pat.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=459196

[Achmed]

It is an upgrade at RB, though not a huge one. The drop off at WR, though, is giant. I would pass.

Return the favor?
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=459259

[Carnac]

Before anyone answered I pulled the trade. I like Brown's schedule over Grant's, but not THAT much I guess. Thanks for the answers.

[Achmed]

Could you still help us out with ours?