Was Offered - Brady/Smith(CAR) for Rodgers/SJax

[the izzy]

Yahoo, h2h keeper league. Keep 3 players. I'm 7-1, first place.

0.5 PPR league. 0.5 pt per completion, 3 pt bonus at 100 rush yrds / 100 rec yrds / 300 passing yrds.

I was offered: T. Brady + S. Smith (CAR)
I give up: S. Jackson + A. Rodgers

I'm worried about Rodgers not making it thru the year, but I definitely do not want to give up S.Jackson. My original offer was A.Rodgers + S. Smith (NYG) for same two players. What should I counter? A. Rodgers + Smith + Bradshaw? Or, I could go A.Rodgers + S. Jackson for Brady, Smith, Slaton. Slaton has low value right now.

My team:
QB: Rodgers
RB: Rice
RB: S. Jackson
WR: Calvin
WR: Boldin
WR: S. Smith (NYG)
TE: Z. Miller
RB/WR: Lynch
BN: Bradshaw (RB), D. Brown (RB), W. Parker (RB), Moreno (RB), Hester (WR), R. Williams (WR), Cooley (TE)

K: Folk
DEF: SD (GB)

His team:
QB: Brady
RB: Slaton
RB: T. Jones
WR: R. Wayne
WR: Burleson
WR: S. Smith (CAR)
TE: Tony G.
RB/WR: D. Mason
BN: Walter, Carnell, Hasselbeck, Dustin Keller, Ward, Sproles, Royal
K: Tynes
DEF: NO (NYJ)

K: Folk
DEF: SD (GB)

[the izzy]

bump - WHIR, leave link

[Achmed]

I don't think I'd make any deal. Yes, Rodgers' line could get him killed. But you have to make the assumption that he plays all season. And if he does, his numbers won't be that far off from Brady's. You are already starting three WR's better than Carolina Smith. So essentially you are giving up SJax for a little improvement at QB and nothing else. I wouldn't do that.

Return the favor?
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=459259