Tough trade question! WHIR

[FeArMeNtL]

I was just offered Pierre Thomas and Dwayne Bowe for Jonathan Stewart and Hines Ward. I feel Pierre Thomas and Bowe have real good upside but am I giving up too much?

We start 1 QB 2 RB 2 WR 1 TE 1 K 1 DEF

QB- T. Romo, E. Manning
RB- MJD, Kevin Smith, J. Stewart, J. Fargas, J. Forsett
WR- Andre Johnson, M. Colston, H. Ward, D. Driver
TE- T. Scheffler, T. Heap
K- Gostkowski, J. Brown
Def- Steelers, Saints.

[endlessMike]

I think it sounds like a fair trade.

[Hoosierdad]

Given your solid WRs, I think I would do this. I think Thomas has much better upside than your other RB2. Ward is good, but you have AJ and Colston, so this helps your starting lineup.

help?
viewtopic.php?t=459307

[Moose484848]

That IS a tough one!! i think J stew is a little more consistent thatn Pierre, and I think that Bowe is a little bit better than Hines, but I think Rbs are more valuable, so I like the trade for you bc you upgrade at RB slightly while losing at WR slightly but the RB being more valuable makes it better for you.. In my opinion.

Can you please help with mine??

viewtopic.php?t=459300