Boldin/Mendy/Coffee for Sjax/knox/forsett WHIR

[Montana168]

it is a yahoo DYNASTY league (keep all players every year, 2 rd draft each yr for rookies)...standard scoring plus 6 pts for passing TD's and 5 bonus points when a rb gets over 200 yds rushing or a wr gets over 200 yds receiving. here is the deal:

I GET:
Anquan Boldin
Rashard Mendenhall
Glenn Coffee

I GIVE UP:
Steven Jackson
Johnny Knox
Justin Forsett

so basically its boldin/mendy for s jax. the other players dont matter to me in the deal. i liked the deal a lot at first but after talkin to some other people in my league, i'm kind of not liking but need other opinions. if boldin was healthy i'd do this in a heartbeat but he's not. mendy has looked good but only has 4 starts under his belt and s jax is already a proven stud. heres my team:

Tied for 3rd (5-3)
QB big ben
WR colston
WR crabtree
WR cotchery
RB peterson
RB gore
TE witten
W/R s jax
BN knox
BN felix jones
BN choice
BN andre caldwell
BN chester taylor
BN mike bell
BN brandon tate (stashing)
BN justin forsett
BN john carlson
BN mathew stafford

boldin is clearly an upgrade that i need at WR3 but is it worth the downgrade at RB? mendenhall is 4 yrs younger than s jax and for all we know could end up becoming even better than s jax but we just dont kno yet. also do you think boldin will be healthy for the stretch run? obviously no one knows but if he can stay on the field he has amazing matchups the rest of the way including vs. STL and DET in the playoffs.

as always leave a link and i'll help u out.

[eaglesfan]

Is Mendenhall the clear starter in Pitt? I have followed that situation at all. I personally like S Jax over both players. Boldin is banged up a lot as well.

[I Think Im Bowie]

If its a dynasty league, I say you have to pounce......S Jax might not be around for a while....unless he gets trade. But I think Mendi will be the man in PIT next year....they will prob spend some picks on o-line too.....plus I think Boldin is a great buy-low candadite....I think you arent gonna get much more value out of sjax than this, and he did just have a big game so now is the time to move him if you can.

[daytripper]

I would go for it. Steven jackson has no value in the future

Mendenhall will be the go to guy in future

boldin is a good pick up also

thanks for help on mine

[ftandiama]

it is a yahoo DYNASTY league (keep all players every year, 2 rd draft each yr for rookies)...standard scoring plus 6 pts for passing TD's and 5 bonus points when a rb gets over 200 yds rushing or a wr gets over 200 yds receiving. here is the deal:

I GET:
Anquan Boldin
Rashard Mendenhall
Glenn Coffee

I GIVE UP:
Steven Jackson
Johnny Knox
Justin Forsett

so basically its boldin/mendy for s jax. the other players dont matter to me in the deal. i liked the deal a lot at first but after talkin to some other people in my league, i'm kind of not liking but need other opinions. if boldin was healthy i'd do this in a heartbeat but he's not. mendy has looked good but only has 4 starts under his belt and s jax is already a proven stud. heres my team:

Tied for 3rd (5-3)
QB big ben
WR colston
WR crabtree
WR cotchery
RB peterson
RB gore
TE witten
W/R s jax
BN knox
BN felix jones
BN choice
BN andre caldwell
BN chester taylor
BN mike bell
BN brandon tate (stashing)
BN justin forsett
BN john carlson
BN mathew stafford

boldin is clearly an upgrade that i need at WR3 but is it worth the downgrade at RB? mendenhall is 4 yrs younger than s jax and for all we know could end up becoming even better than s jax but we just dont kno yet. also do you think boldin will be healthy for the stretch run? obviously no one knows but if he can stay on the field he has amazing matchups the rest of the way including vs. STL and DET in the playoffs.

as always leave a link and i'll help u out.

thanks for your help on mine....

I'd stick to what you guy. you look pretty solid already and i like sjax in your line up

[MadDog36]

Insanity to say SJax has no future value. He has 3 more years of productivity left. However, Mendenhall is and considered by many experts to be a top 3 dynasty RB, just behind MJD and AD

[Montana168]

thanks for all the help guys. i eneded up doing the deal bcuz i like how my WR look with boldin and i really think mendenhall could become a top 10 back or better, especially since fwp is on his way out for sure next year. sucks losing s jax but his value right now is the highest its been all season, i traded for him in this league and in another keeper league at the beginning of the yr bcuz nobody wanted him, so i got a great return value i think. if boldin was healthy right now, no shot i would hav gotten this deal, so i'm willing to take the risk. thanks again.