Need Trade Help!! WHIR!

[theckeriiii]

10 Team PPR: 2RB's, 2 WR's 1RB/WR flex, 1WR/TE flex

I am on a tough run-was 4-1, and a month later am 4-5. Have lost 3 of 4 by less than 5 pts each time. I think I need to shake things up a bit and have been offered the following trade:

I give up: S Jax, Mike Sims-Walker and Jamaal Charles
I get: M Barber, Ochocinco and D Driver

Am leaning toward doing it but am torn. Thinking about countering w Celek instead of MSW. Trade reduces me at RB (I only have to start 2 per week), but pick up better production at WR.

Could really use some help with this.

WHIR-leave link. Thanks.

[TheBambino]

Thanks for your help

This is a close one.... Id probably do it... S Jax is hard to lose but I dont think Sims Walker puts up last week's numbers again.... and Jamall may not even be the #1 with smith on his heels.... With your 2 WR and 2 flex with WR, I think it would be good to get Ocho and driver in there... you can usually count on them to be #1 targets every week.... can you count on Jamall?

But i wouldnt really be upset either way you choose.. hope this helps!

[METS 24]

Deleted

[overbore]

I have SJax (13) + MSW (15) + JCharles (59 - but lets say he's a 45 Like LJ)
You get M Barber (24) + Ochocinco (10) + Driver (14)

This is tough - SJax gets lots of carries & I don't particularly like Barber. But you get 2 starting WR's for one which looks like the deal breaker for me. I say if you are hurting at WR can give up a RB pull the trigger.

PS. I disagree with above. Marion Barber << Steven Jackson!

[thriftstorejedi]

I second Mets24's opinion - go for it!

[Hoosierdad]

I would only do this if you need a WR. I think Jax>barber by a fair amount. But if you need 2 WRs, then this is a good deal. But if you are set at WR, don't do it.