WHIR: Cutler or McNabb? Flip a coin for 3rd receiver?

[Bulard280]

Hey guys so I need your help, I don't know who to start at QB:

McNabb vs. Chargers
Cutler vs. 49ers
Hasselbeck vs. Cardinals

I am leaning towards Cutler but I'm not sure on McNabb

At WR we start 3 and I have no idea who to play at my 3rd WR: (Nicks and Kevin Walter byes hurt)
Brandon Marshall vs. Redskins (Yes)
Mike Wallace vs. Bengals (Yes)
TO vs. Titans
Donnie Avery vs. NO
Ted Ginn vs. TB

And I am right to be starting Westbrook, LT, and Forte at my 2 RB and 1 Flex positions? or should I only go with two of these guys and plug in a WR at my flex? Thanks for the help leave a link and I will help you out.

[twakeman]

I'd go Cutler and TO (providing he plays)
If not, then Avery or Ginn is pretty much a toss up, but I'd give Avery a run.

And yes, I think the 3 RBs is probably the way to go, providing Westbrook plays as well.

[cutiepie80]

Mcnabb and TO....if to doesn't play take Ginn.

[LJcomeback09]

CUTLER!

[AJax728]

I would be careful about Westbrook as he is apparently now complaining about his ankle (and his concussion). I would give him a week or two to prove himself.

I'd also say McNabb over Cutler. SF held Peyton Manning to no TD's, and Cutler makes mistakes that a defense like SF would capitalize on. SD's pass defense is overrated because of a favorable 'pass friendly' schedule.

[pokashark24]

Cutler is a riskier play....he is a high risk/high reward kinda guy. If you're feeling lucky and like upside of 300+ yards and 2+TD's go with Cutler. But realize he could also throw a bunch of INTs and have a crappy day too.

I think the safer bet here is McNabb and that's prolly who I'd roll with. Chargers are looking good lately and this game could be very high scoring. I like McNabb this week for about 275+ yards and 2-3 TD's. Go with McNabb he's solid and safe.


You are in a tough spot at WR man.....I guess you go with T.O. even though he's been a joke this year. If he doesn't play go with Donnie Avery....at least he is the #1 WR (even if it is the Rams)

Also check the status of Westbrook he doesn't sound like he is gonna play this week.

Thanks for the help on mine.

[debro23]

Mcnabb has been off lately so I would go with Cutler

viewtopic.php?f=19&t=460393

[rockwell81]

Cutler and TO. Cutler will have to throw this week, and TO is better than your other options.


viewtopic.php?f=19&t=460629