Ryan or Garrard?

[JethroSpanks]

Who do I start at QB...Ryan or Garrard? What are your feelings on Ryan's recent performances? I feel like he has more potential for explosive awesomeness AND horrible 3-INT awfulness. Then again, Garrard seems to be a bit more reliable without the potential for the extreme level of awesomeness but better ball protection. Maybe, what I'm really curious about is the matchups of Ryan vs Carolin DEF and Garrard vs. NYJ DEF.

I'm tempted to start Garrard just because of Ryan's recent performances and seeing him not fare too well against my Cowboys. However, they have a better pass rush than Carolina. But does Garrard have enough weapons when Revis takes our MSW?

*sigh*

Please help!

[Hank's Scorpions]

I would go with Ryan here. He has got to come back at some point. Both QB's have issues with thier #1 WR this week, I just think that Atlanta has a few other weapons to use. I will be following this thread because a I too have these bozo's on my bench with Favre starting. Which ever of thoose guys play better will stay on my team (although Atltanta has a tough playoff schedule.

[latsprewell20002000]

Eh id still play Ryan over Garrard lol.

[JethroSpanks]

See, in my mind they both have really good #1's, really good RBs, and really good TE's.

*sigh*

Thank you both for your replies! It'll be a last minute decision

[bmault]

No possible way I play Garrard on the road at the Jets who are coming off a bye.

mine:
viewtopic.php?t=460957