Fitzgerald for Forte? Addai for Ricky the Weed?

[Newkie]

I am in a 12 manager PPR keeper league with normal H2H scoring. I was offered Forte, Chris Chambers and Steve Breaston for my Fitzgerald, Fred Jackson and my first round pick. I am in second as I type, so chances are I will have a low number one high number two. Would you do this offer? or this next one?

His Ricky Williams, Lynch, Hasselbeck for my Addai, Romo, and Garcon.
Do you like either? If so which?
My players are:

Romo
Fitz
Ward
Bowe
Braylon Edwards
Grant
Caddy
Addai
Freddie Jackson
Garcon
Knox
Brown

Thanks