Trade Wells or Mendenhall for Bowe in dynasty? WHIR

[matttyl315]

With Bowe out 4 weeks, his owner in my league is looking to trade so he can still hope to make the playoffs. I'm stacked at young RBs, so he came to me. I can trade either Wells or Mendenhall for Bowe, and either Suggs or Cole (DL) or a 2nd round rookie pick next year. I could use another WR, but I don't know if I need one this bad. We start 1 QB, 1 RB, 2 WR, 2 FLEX, 1 TE, K, IDP. Any and all advice would be greatly appreciated. I'm at 7-3 right now, and going to make the playoffs, which way would be better once Bowe is back?

Rodgers, A Smith, Hass, Vick
Rice, Moreno, Mendenhall, Wells, J Charles, B Scott
R White, B Marshall, Crabtree, L Evans, A Bryant, Cribbs, Garcon, Mike Thomas
V Davis, Keller, Z Miller
Folk, Tynes
Mathis, Kampman (can start at DL), William Hayes
Beason, Briggs, Durant, Tatupu (on IR)
Harper, Tanard Jackson, Mikell, Adrian Wilson, C Griffin

[matttyl315]

Anyone? I think this would balance my RBs with my WRs, but since I only have to start 2 WRs each week, I kinda like having 4 RB studs and I pick the best 3 matchups. Oh, and it's pretty much half a point per reception (we get bonuses at 5, 8, and 10 catches per game).

[matttyl315]

As our league is always talking amongst each other, another owner got wind of this offer, and has offered me up Vincent Jackson for either Wells or Mendenhall. Which way should I go, if either? Thanks so much!

[Pack Fan in HTown]

If I had a choice I would go with Wells for Jackson here.
Jackson will have more upside over the next few years. And I truly think Wells success is tied to Warner being there. When Leinart steps in his value will take a severe hit as def can stack up against the run.

please help with mine
viewtopic.php?t=461758

[BALCO All-Stars]

Pass on giving up either guy for Bowe, but I would definitely take Wells for V-Jax.

Help: viewtopic.php?t=461778

[matttyl315]

Yeah, I think I'm over Bowe, but I just hate giving up young stud RBs. Wells is the future, there, right? I know that V Jax is a stud as well, but I've got White and Marshall and the up-and-coming Crabtree already. Anyone else have an opinion on it? I really like having the "monopoly" on sub-25 starting RBs in the NFL (Rice, Moreno, Mendenhall, Wells and Charles).

[matttyl315]

Now the whole league is on this! The Welker owner said he'd do a 1-1, and the Colston owner did the same.

So, should I trade Wells, and if so, would I want Bowe, V Jax, Welker or Colston in return?