R.Moss/Snelling for Roddy/Mendenhall

[snixx79]

12 team H2H yahoo performance pool, .5pt per reception

I lost Ronnie Brown, luckliy i still have MJD. I have been offered the following:

Roddy/Mendenhall(Or McCoy) for Randy Moss/Snelling

Is this worth giving up Moss for? Other than Jones-Drew, my backs are now Maroney/Snelling/Cadillac. So i need the upgrade.
He also has DeSean Jackson who he will trade insteda of White.

Please advise!!

WHIR!! Leave a link!!

[pangbones]

You and I are in the same boat. But you're in a much better position than I am. I would take that if it were offered to me. I don't think you lose much going from Moss to White. I'd prefer White to Jackson, but you could go either way IMO. I think it's a pretty good deal for you.

Heres mine
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=461618

[The D]

I would pull the trigger for sure. White is a notch below Moss, but you are getting a solid above average back who I am personally really high on at this point. You are upgrading your backs tremendously, while not taking a huge hit at WR spot. And I would take White over Jackson.....

[bounce]

I'd take that trade. Moss is obviously the best player involved, but if you can get solid #2 numbers out of Roddy, your team looks a lot better when RM instead of Maroney in your lineup.

Help me please? viewtopic.php?t=461630

[Maris09]

I'd do it.

[Indibuck]

Yeah I would probably do this deal. I would take Mendy over McCoy.

[popew626]

I would probably do that deal.

Please help me here, I'm in a similar situation
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=461783

[schmidty]

Not much to add. This is a good deal for you. Roddy is a downgrade from Moss, but still good. And Mendenhall gives you a huge upgrade at RB (most importantly, a guy who's role we know for the rest of the season).

Help in return? viewtopic.php?f=18&t=461837

[NFL1527]

Totally agree with all the statements above. It is important you address your current weakness which happens to be RB and you are doing that by adding Mendenhall. Roddy is a downgrade from Moss but not by that much. GO FOR IT!

Please help with mine: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=461845&p=3156496#p3156496

Thanks!

[MadDog36]

Mendy and White.