Would you rather have Schaub or Manning for the playoffs?

[pepperoncino]

i have an opportunity to make a deadline deal where i give up manning and breaston and get schaub, crabtree and lesean mccoy. i'm 8-2 and in good position to make the playoffs so i'm thinking ahead here...colts should have their playoff spot wrapped up earlier than ever, but manning's never sat or been limited in week 16 (our season ends then, so i'm not worried about week 17, when he's surely rest)... do you think that will happen this year?

schaub
week 15 @ stl
week 16 @ mia

manning
week 15 @ jac
week 16 nyj

all things considered, and the fact that the deal is sweetened by getting mccoy (don't desperately need him, but he would get some flex starts for me), do i do this or hold on to what i've got?

thanks!!!!

[titans_cafe]

Manning should be better, but if you feel that you need a better RB, then perhaps the deal is a good one.

help me? viewtopic.php?t=461784

[spodog]

I'd rather have Manning. He'll be chasing Marino's record (he may say he doesn't care, but it will be in the back of his mind), plus he has the experience.

Schaub is one hit away from walking off the field for the rest of the season. Manning doesn't miss games. Ever.

Mine:
http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=461793