please help with this trade proposal, WHIR

[ab100]

I give away:
Matt Ryan, Atl QB
Send Ray Rice, Bal RB

I get:
Receive Beanie Wells, Ari RB
Receive Philip Rivers, SD QB

I have Matt Ryan as my starting QB. My backup is Vince Young...exactly! My RBs are MJD, Rice, Slaton, Brown. This is a standard scoring league, 10yrds/pt receive/rush, 6pts for TD rush/receive/pass, 50yrds pass/pt.

[Hoosierdad]

Man, all these tough trades. I really like Rice. I can see why you want to upgrade your QB. The question is, how confident are you in Slaton or Wells? You are trading a top 5 RB and replacing him with either of them. Personally, but if you feel good with Slaton and/or Wells, pull the trigger. It's by no means a bad deal.

help?
viewtopic.php?t=461767

[schmidty]

I know these deadline offers are tough. But I think Rice has really proven he's an absolute stud this year. I'd only trade him for one of the trinity of QBs: Brees, Brady, Manning. If you had a decent backup, this would be ok. But who do you have at RB after MJD? Slaton (unpredictable share with Moats), Wells (unpredictable share with Hightower), and Brown (always hurt this year, and clearly behind Addai). I don't think I'd do it.

Help in return? viewtopic.php?f=18&t=461837

[MadDog36]

I would do this deal since your not upsetting the apple cart and gaining an upgrade.

Wells is on his way up. I think I would do this.

[brianj29]

I would ,ryan has not been consistent,yes rice is a stud but rivers is lights out and wells is getting better and better and with cake schedule rest of way good luck

help:
viewtopic.php?t=461907

[THEWALL31]

I would pass on this to , rice and mjd are a great duo to have at Rb
if Ryan busts out any more you can always play the QB match up game each week with your wire against bad d's , after all the RB that went down last week all starting RB value has gone up and you have 2 of the top 5
good luck please help on mine
viewtopic.php?f=19&t=461952

[jhurstjunior]

Thanks for the help with mine. I would suggest you roll with the team you have. Having both Rice and MJD is a great duo and they will consistently get you more points than you would get out of Rivers over Ryan on any given week.

[issaquah stud]

Thanks for the help w/mine.

You told me to trade Big Ben and Beanie for Deangelo

Granted, I have Schaub but I think top RB's are keys to winning championships...not trading them away.

Keep MJD/Rice, especially w/Turner out they may have to pass more resulting in Ryan's stats going up a bit