My Gore/A.Johnson for His DeAngelo/V.Jackson..WHIR 100%

[NFL1527]

Hey guys,

This trade was just proposed to me...

I receive:
RB-DeAngelo Williams
WR-Vincent Jackson

I give up:
RB-Frank Gore
WR-Andre Johnson

Here is my current team:
QB-Romo, Palmer
RB-MJD,Gore,Jacobs,Bush,Forsett,Wells
WR-A.Johnson,R.White,S.Rice,D.Mason,R.Williams,A.Gonzalez,A.Collie
TE-Witten
K-Tynes
DST-Eagles,Seahawks

Here is the team I am trading with:
QB-Brees,Orton
RB-DeAngelo,M.Barber,Mendenhall,Snelling,Buckhalter
WR-Jackson,Boldin,Sims-Walker,Manningham,Wallace,Knox
TE-Gonzalez
K-Gostkowski
DST-NO,Baltimore


What do you guys think about this trade? As you can see the other manager is pretty weak at the RB position as he lost Ronnie Brown. He is pretty adamant about getting Gore + a top WR off me. Please look at my team. If I were to give up Gore what do you think would be a return that would be worth my while? Thanks in advance for all your responses. WHIR 100%!

[schmidty]

Ehh ... I don't really see what this trade does for your team to make it better. Gore and DWill rate about the same in my book. And going from AJohnson to VJackson is a downgrade. So the trade looks really lateral with you coming out behind on a total talent level. I'd stand pat.

[cardinalram]

it's awfully silly to ever trade two players at two positions for two players of the same level of play at the same two positions. no reason to do it, it doesn't help you, or hurt you. imo it's a slight slight upgrade in rb, but a bit of a downgrade in wr.

[MadDog36]

RB-Frank Gore
WR-Andre Johnson

I'd take this side. There is no reason to do this deal unless you are in love with DWill and Vjax.

[brianj29]

NO WAY!!!!
gor and johnson much better playoff schedule gore gets more receptions and doesn't split carries

help
viewtopic.php?t=461907