Good or Bad Trade??

[Homer525]

10 team h2h ppr league (QB, RB, RB, WR, WR, WR/RB, TE, K, D)

Currenty 4-6 with only 3 weeks remaining until playoffs and wanted to do something instead of stand pat....please let me know if I made the right move in this trade.

Brady/Jennings/P. Thomas/Cotchery
for
Rodgers/Colston/Mendenhall/Olsen

My team before trade:

QB- Brady
RB-Thomas
RB- Barber
WR- Ocho
WR- Jennings
WR/RB- Burelson
TE- Heap
K- Crosby
D- Minny

Bench: Westbrook/Bell/Cotchery/Snelling/S. Moss/Maroney


After trade:

QB- Rodgers
RB- Mendy
RB- Barber
WR- Ocho
WR- Colston
WR/RB- Burelson
TE- Olsen
K- Crosby
D- Minny

Bench: Westbrook/Bell/Snelling/Moss/Maroney

[schmidty]

Big big trade ... but when you're 4-6 it might not hurt to shake things up. I think you did fine. With the exception of the Cotchery/Olsen part you did the same thing in each case: trade away the bigger pre-season "name" for guy that actually outperform them through 10 weeks. Rodgers vs Brady, Mendy vs PT, Colston vs Jennings. A gutsy move, but if I was a betting man I'd bet your new players as a whole score more than the guys you traded away. Though its certainly close. And with Cotchery/Olsen you trade a bench WR for a better TE. So I'd say you did well, though with so many players involved it can certainly end up going either way.

Help in return? viewtopic.php?t=461837

[MadDog36]

Rodgers/Colston/Mendenhall/Olsen

Eh close at QB, Rodgers is underrated. Colston is an upgrade, kinda push at RB, but I'd rather have Mendy. Olsen meh nice upgrade at TE.

I think if it ain't broke why fix it, but if you need to shake things up to change your fortune then go for it.

Its not a bad deal either way. It might not even make a difference.