ESPN deadline @ 12E, need help; Williams for Schuab? WHIR

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

deadline is a 12 eastern, this offer was just proposed to me:

i give: deanglo williams
i get: matt schuab

small league (8 teams), and I'm fairly stacked at RB...i'm trying to plan for the playoffs
1pt for 50 passing yds; 3pt bonus over 300; 6pt passing td
1pt for 20 rushing yds; 2pt bonus over 100; 6pt rushing/receiving td

schuab playoff matchups (sea, stl, mia)
mcnabb playoff matchups (nyg, sf, den)
d.williams (ne, min, nyg)
b.jacobs (phi, was, car
f.gore (ari, phi, det)

EDIT: i couldn't pull the trigger, though i probably should have (especially with d.williams playoff schedule)...but something in my gut kept saying no

my team
qb: mcnabb
rb: AP
rb: d.williams
w/r: f.gore
wr: a.boldin
wr: r.white
te: k.winslow
def: chargers
k: n.keading
bn: j.flacco
bn: b.jacobs
bn: a.bradshaw
bn: b.wells
bn: TO
bn: braylon edwards
bn: jason witten
bn: ravens

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

addendum: other guy has Brady, Farve, and Schuab at QB

[MadDog36]

For Brady, yes I would.

If that's the only QB upgrade you can get, I'd still do it, you have RB depth.

If you do the deal cut one of your remaining QBs for a replacement RB.

[federally88]

You looked stacked at rb..Gore seems to have an easy playoff run.. Schaub is playing good right now...I always worry about McNabb....Looks like you will improve..good luck

[WaCougMBS]

For Brady, yes I would.

If that's the only QB upgrade you can get, I'd still do it, you have RB depth.

If you do the deal cut one of your remaining QBs for a replacement RB.

X2

Try for Brady or grab Schaub if he won't budge...

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

i couldn't pull the trigger, though i probably should have (especially with d.williams playoff schedule)...but something in my gut kept saying no

[StriKing_Cobra]

I'd like to see Brady instead of Shaub. However you're going to improve with either. Even if you did Gore for Brady.

Most Brady owners won't budge on him (me included)

[cork95]

thxs for mine

I'd do it...he's put up consistent numbers and has great matchups coming up

[MadDog36]

I would reup the trade and offer him several deals including the one he offered you. Should go for it dude.

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

i would love to repropose it, but the trading deadline for the league has come and went.

here's my reasons for declining it; feel free to disagree
1) PHI has been throwing the ball 40-50 times a game. i figured mcnabb had just as good as a chance as schuab as putting up good numbers; granted schaub has the easier playoff opponents
2) I need to win this week and next week to even get into the playoffs; and with d.williams and b.jacobs gimpy legs, I need all the help I can get these next 2 weeks
3) i was also hoping that d.williams gets hot like he did last year during the stretch run

thoughts?