URGENT help needed MONSTER TRADE

[jackarmani]

Ray Rice and Steve Slaton for Michael Turner and Cedric Benson

Which guy gets better deal?

[Hoosierdad]

That would depend on rosters, but if the Turner/Benson guy can get to the playoffs, that would be a great pair. Turner may not play for a couple more weeks though.

[jackarmani]

yeah that would be me getting Turner and Benson. I also have chris Johnson so my RB core would be superb.

The only reason i'd do this is because Rice has to face steelers away in the final week of the playoffs. A tough matchup especially when both teams are fighting for postseason spots.

But with Turner against Jets and Buffalo and Benson against Kansas and San Diego I would be sitting pretty.

As for getting to playoffs. At the moment I have a one game lead in my league from 2nd place. And I am 2 wins above 5th place. So things look good for me reaching the playoffs.

[Flyn high again]

Slaton is at best, a RB by committee situation. No guarantee he is someone to start for the rest of the season. Rice is good but not as good as either Turner or Benson. Latest RotoWorld report has Turner already back to limited practice. I'd make this trade in a second.

Help me if you like... viewtopic.php?t=462554

[MadDog36]

Michael Turner and Cedric Benson side wins easily.

Go get Scott, if you can...

[jackarmani]

yeah unluckily I was too late. He withdrew the trade offer.

So i'm looking to counter to another offer now.

I have chris Johnson who i'd probably play every week anyway in the playoffs. So i'll only offer for one of his Michael Turner or Cedric Benson. But which?

What would be a trade you think would be best? These are our 2 teams

Me:
Brett Favre, Eli Manning
Chris johnson, Ray Rice, Steve Slaton, Darren McFadden
Calvin Johnson, Dwayne Bowe, Desean Jackson, Donald Driver, Michael Crabtree
kellen Winslow
Neil Rackers
Saints DST

Him:
Donovan McNabb, Kevin Kolb
Michael Turner, Cedric Benson, Ladainian Tomlinson, Ricky Williams (BEAST IN RBS)
Chad Ochocinco, Roddy White, Percy Harvin, Braylon Edwards
Dallas Clark
Jay Feely
Dolphins DST, Broncos DST

I was thinking: Ray Rice + Calvin Johnson for Michael Turner + Chad Ochocinco