Roddy or Sims-Walker (WHIR)

[toobitter]

2 dilemmas

#1 priority is which WR do i start in non PPR
Roddy White or Mike Sims-Walker
Been leaning towards MSW, but I'll feel very stupid if Roddy finally goes off again.

Issue #2
PPR league
Pick one for flex
Pierre Thomas, Cadillac Williams, Rock Cartwright, Steve Breaston, Chris Chambers, Devin Hester

[contois319]

Personally, I like Roddy and then Pierre. NE can be run on, and I dont feel that Roddy should be benched in any league, or any format.

[Delhomme17]

I like MSW in the first league because of Ryan's recent struggles and the fact that Jennings burned the Niners last week

In the second league, I think your only option is Thomas. Cartwright is a sexier pick, but I think Thomas finds paydirt and I'm not sure Rock does.

Here's mine: http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=19&t=462822

[carter]

Roddy appears healthy (finally?) ..if he is, i think you have to start him... if you dont feel good about him, MSW is not far off a healthy Roddy anyways

Flex - as a Thomas owner, i say start Rock Cartwright.. it flat out sucks to watch Bush/Bell get all the td's so far

viewtopic.php?f=19&t=462721

[mr00]

Roddy White has easier matchup as TB allows a lot of fantasy pts to opposing WR (24.6). SF allows 22.1. Neither team really has a shut down corner. You should feel good starting either but again I would play Roddy White also because he is 100%.

Hope I helped.

[PackersForever]

Roddy White (in a close call)

[3TimeChampFTW]

I think Roddy/PT give you the highest risk/reward where as MSW/Rock are the safer picks. If your up against a dominant team, I would roll with Roddy/PT and hope PT gives you one of those amazing performances that he has lacked the last 3 weeks (I have him, he's extremely frustrating). If your up against a mediocre opponent I would roll with the MSW/Rock as they should give you a more guaranteed decent point total.

thanks for helping me

[bmfbonfire]

First, Thanks for the help.

I like White over MSW this week. He is going against a defense that likes to give multiple touchdowns to WR. You can't go wrong with Thomas.

[njnewc]

I like MSW and I like Rock here... you picked him up to play him so lets roll the dice...

viewtopic.php?t=462817