Well, I'm just a little torn on this one but for the most part I'm very pleased with this. He did a great job at finding value defensively even with the Cory Redding and Colin Cole whiffs. And the 2009 draft is likely to be looked upon as his best. But ultimately he didn't put together the proper staff and never helped out offensively. Furthermore, he'll always be the guy that let Steve Hutchinson go and signed Shaun Alexander to that ridiculous contract. Clearly this was the exact opposite way it should have gone. After reading exactly what happened with Hutch it's difficult to completely lay blame on him (the poison pill was the real culprit), but regardless Hutch should have been locked up before then.
Now it appears we're a Rooney rule away from getting Holmgren back as the GM. If this is the case I've very excited. Too many people think Holmgren struggled as GM but the guy is one of the smartest minds in football and I doubt anyone could say he wouldn't learn from his mistakes and with the proper focus be one of the best in the business. It clearly helps that he has the respect of the league too.
My single concern is that he doesn't come in and really put the pressure on our current coaching staff. They need a wake up call in a big way, especially Knapp. He's been good in spots and bad in streaks, which isn't a favorable review of his playcalling.
Anyway, I hope the Holmgren talk isn't merely speculation.