Tomlinson or Pierre Thomas, WHIR..

[ivanhack]

Should I start Tomlinson @ Dal or Pierre Thomas @ Atl?

I also have Benson @ MIN but I think I have to roll with Benson no matter what.

What do you guys think? Roster & Scoring listed below:

WHIR....

IDP League w/ 2 QB's

Scoring:
Passing TD 4 points
Rushing or Receiving TD 4 points
Rushing or Receiving 10 yards 1 point
Passing 25 yards 1 point

Defense Scoring:
Tackle or Assisted tackle 1 point
Sack 3 points
Interception 4 points
Touchdown 4 points
Forced Fumbles 1 points

My Roster:

QB: Peyton Manning
QB: Ben Roethlisberger
RB: Ladainian Tomlinson
RB: Cedric Benson
WR: Donald Driver
WR: Wes Welker
WR: Percy Harvin
TE: Brent Celek
IDP: James Farrior
IDP: Antoine Bethea
IDP: Bradie James
IDP: Lance Briggs

BN: Mark Sanchez, Pierre Thomas, Reggie Bush, Mike Bell, Bernard Scott, Ahmad Bradshaw, Hines Ward, Eddie Royal, EJ Henderson, Daniel Manning

[jhurstjunior]

I would give the nod to LT. He has been playing well as of late. With PT it is tough to know who will be getting a lot of the carries. Help with mine: viewtopic.php?f=19&t=463965

[graphix28]

man that's tough, if PT was playing full time it would be a no brainer.. I'm not sure LT can have a great game against Dallas. LT gets goal lines, I'd probably go with him. but it's close

thanks for helping me

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

really tough one here.

DAL is tough against the run, but LT gets all of SD goalline carries
ATL is also tough against the run, but the with the NO high scoring offense they can move it on anyone to get into goalline situations and have proven to be faithful in their running game. But PT isn't guaranteed goalline carries.


i'd go with LT whose been hot as of late

[ltrocq]

go LT regardless of the matchup. once SD gets in the redzone he will be given the ball. the same can't be said for PT.

[crazysparky]

LT he sees endzone alot

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

with TD only being 4 pts there isn't as much emphasis on Goalline. yards are easier to come by. But i still give LT the edge

[dpaine1988]

LT has a nose for the endzone and is clearly still the #1 back in SD

Pierre is such a gamble, you never know who is gonna get the carries and where and when your gonna ge them.

viewtopic.php?f=19&t=463971