Ganther vs Oak or Barber vs SD ? WHIR

[rjoyner17]

Please offer some insight this is a tough one.

[slick56]

Barber for sure!! i think he is due for a decent game and TD

[Bucktail30]

That's a tough one. Barber has been the victim of a recent pass heavy offense in Dallas. We haven't seen much of Ganther but he does have a great matchup against the Raiders. Ganther has the bigger upside this week and Barber has done nothing significant recently. Go with Ganther.

[KeithJ]

I think Ganther definitely has the most upside. I'd go with him.

[rjoyner17]

Thanks Guys ! I was leaning toward barber but I may pull the plug on the bigger name and go with the unknown.

[Montana168]

you have to go with barber. i know barber has struggled all yr and its anyones guess to who will get a TD between him, felix and choice but ganther, IMO has to show us something before he can legitimately be started over a player like barber. also, i expect the cowboys to run all over SD who has been without their pro bowl NT all season, but their secondary is very talented but due to the lack of a pass rush, they look worse than they are right now. barber is the safer choice to get a 80 or more total yds and a td or two.

thanks for the help with mine.

[reemaskain]

I'd go with barber

[leiris]

i'd go off the matchup, so Ganther.

viewtopic.php?t=464102

[MorF3Us]

washington's offense is still at the bottom of the barrel. Plus, last week's defeat was sooo deflating that I don't see the skins rebounding.

MBIII

[Hags888]

Barber is in a rotation backfield in Dallas. Felix Jones AND Tashard Choice have been getting touches, and they are up against an improving D in SD. Combined with the fact that Dallas is pass-heavy recently, and I'd not touch this with a 10-foot poll.

Ganther, while a total risk play in that he's unknown, has a very soft matchup, and the Redskins have traditionally been a run-first team. Their offense has improved a great deal since they hired their new play caller. Zorn must have seen something he liked to give Ganther the start over a career backup in Cartright. In your situation, I'd start Ganther.

I have a similar question on my own squad! Help with mine?

viewtopic.php?t=464194
viewtopic.php?t=464192