MSW vs. Indy or Walter @ St Louis? WHIR

[rozzz5]

This is my first playoff week (I had a bye last week as the 2nd seed) and I'm going crazy with this decision.
Sims Walker has done absolutely nothing the last 3 weeks, although until then he was pretty productive in home games. On the other hand, Walter has been a huge disappointment this year and although he has a nice matchup, he's done nothing in previous "nice matchups" as well. Is there any chance of Walter having a huge game?

None of them are great options but there's no one better on the waiver wire (unless you think Hester or Breaston are better starts).

What say you?

Leave a link and i'll help with yours.

12 team league. Standard scoring (No PPR) 4 pts for Passing TD's, 6 for all others. 1 pt. - 25 passing yards and 10 rushing/receiving yards. We can play a QB in the flex spot.
RELEASE THE HOUNDS (9-4)
SLOT PLAYER, TEAM POS
QB Aaron Rodgers, GB QB
RB DeAngelo Williams, Car RB
RB Cedric Benson, Cin RB
WR Calvin Johnson, Det WR P
WR Kevin Walter, Hou WR
WR Donald Driver, GB WR
TE Jason Witten, Dal TE
OP Alex Smith, SF QB
D/ST Cardinals D/ST, Ari D/ST
K Nate Kaeding, SD K
Bench Mike Sims-Walker, Jac WR P
Bench Matthew Stafford, Det QB Q
Bench Arian Foster, Hou RB P
Bench Ahmad Bradshaw, NYG RB P
Bench Kerry Collins, Ten QB
IR Donald Brown*, Ind RB O

[dude,micah]

msw

[3TimeChampFTW]

MSW has been garbage lately, but Ithe jags will probably get behing early in this game and have to air it out. I would roll with MSW.


help me out - viewtopic.php?t=464910

[AK513]

Both of them have been diddly poo (Thanks Jim Mora.) But MSW is still their main target. Use him.

viewtopic.php?t=464908

[Madpurple]

MSW hasnt done anything since week 11 - I think Breaston is a better start

posting.php?mode=reply&f=19&t=464726

[KenDawg19]

I have MSW and I'm skeptical about using him this week. Calf (and leg injuries for that matter) are detrimental to WRs. He might not be 100%. I think I would roll with Walter this week.

Thanks for mine.

[dude,micah]

MSW he will be needed against the colts

[verb1999]

Tough to say here, but of your options, I roll with Sims Walker.

[shermcon4]

No contest Mike Sims Walker. Walter is no longer Schaub's go to guy. It's Andre, then Jacoby Jones, then Anderson. He's starting to do more screen passes as well.

[richiro]

concur with everyone else, sims-walker