Peyton vs NYJ or A.Smith vs DET??? WHIR

[gangrene]

not to make your decision any harder but I have a feeling Gore is going to run right through Det and possibly Smiths numbers will be mediocre. Peyton, I think will play 2plus quarters at least unless the jets rough him up which I don't see happening as he gets rid of the ball quickly. I see Peyton throwing over the middle short TDs away from Revis -Lito Sheppard is beatable

[ironcityboy88]

Do NOT BENCH Peyton Manning. DON'T DO IT!!!! Are you going to hinge your entire season, the playoffs, and money on Alex Smith?!?!?!? Say you bench Manning and he gets 250 yards and 2 TD's in one HALF (and he could get more) and A.Smith @#$# you....how are you going to feel the whole off-season?!?!?! Peyton got you there, if your season IS going to end, let it be with him.

[Wile E Coyote]

this one isn't even close
go with smith

please help
viewtopic.php?t=465973

[ironcityboy88]

this one isn't even close
go with smith

please help
viewtopic.php?t=465973

Not even close?!?!?!? You are talkin' about the possible NFL MVP who has kicked some serious tail this year....and you're comparing him to Alex Smith....who's Alex Smith really, c'mon

[Foolio]

Do NOT BENCH Peyton Manning. DON'T DO IT!!!! Are you going to hinge your entire season, the playoffs, and money on Alex Smith?!?!?!? Say you bench Manning and he gets 250 yards and 2 TD's in one HALF (and he could get more) and A.Smith @#$# you....how are you going to feel the whole off-season?!?!?! Peyton got you there, if your season IS going to end, let it be with him.

Ironcityboy, I agree with you... I'm going with Peyton, I trust him!

[arizcats]

Alex Smith, even if Manning does better, it wont be by much. I would have to assume he is doing well that would mean they have a good lead and would presumably be pulled.

Please help...
viewtopic.php?t=466110

[mystykoekaki]

Nod goes to Smith.