Big Ben or Alex Smith

[Voodoo]

Big Ben vs Bal
Alex Smith vs Det

Sure the lions stink! But Big Ben did throw for over 500 yards against what I think is a pretty good Green Bay D.
Who would you start?

[kingmike74]

Do not over think this. BB & Pit are playing for their season v.s. a sub par pass D without their best play. If that does not add up to a good day, I do not know what does.

Do not take it for granted that Smith will throw a ton. I think they get up by 10+ and it turns into the Gore show.


I am not saying Smith will not have 200+ & 2 TD's, just that if I owned Ben, HE WOULD NOT SIT THE REST OF THE YEAR, no matter who I had on the bench.

[Maddeneatshogfat]

Agreed. Don't get cute, start your better player, which is BR.