Wayne For Dejean Jackson in Keeper League

[Nineball]

Wayne is so consitent, but I like Jackson's youth. Also, we count punts and kick returns, so Jackson actually outscored Wayne this year? Upside vs. proven commodity?

[Indibuck]

I'm not sure that DJax will continue to return punts and kicks... I think it more likely that a healthy Maclin or someone else will eventually take that over.

That being said, I think they are both tremendous WRs... but I like the youth aspect of DJax over Wayne. So it's very close... but I would take DJax in a keeper.

[Nineball]

I would agree that Jackson won't be returning kicks much longer. Like Mojo, Westbrook, etc., they become too valuable to risk on special teams.

[latsprewell20002000]

Id rather have the home run hitter than a singles hitter. Im in no way saying Wayne is not good. Just for fantasy purposes Id rather have Jackson. He can win weeks alone by himself sometimes.

[Wolfpac11680]

I say Reggie Wayne without a doubt (IMO).

- Philadelphia doesnt know the QB situation next year so if Kolb is the QB vs Peyton Manning I think Wayne has a huge advantage

- Very true Jackson is a homerun hitter but with the loss of special teams yards/TDs he doesnt have the "option" of having an off game. Reggie Wayne is "relaible" I think he only had 2 games that were double-digits (and I dont count the last 2 weeks since the Colts pulled their starters)

- Both are awesome WRs dont get me wrong, I just would rather play it safe regarding my keepers

[Shaffe]

Desean Jackson is already the better fantasy option, and he's younger. If McNabb isn't back I think Philly will be able to find a QB that can replace his passing skills.

Definitely go with Jackson.

[dblj9911]

I think a lot also depends on the rest of your roster, if you have more of a "youthful" roster that may take another year or two until they are all top notch players then make this deal. If your keepers are more older veterans and you have a shot to make the playoffs then I stick with Wayne. I wouldn't depend on DJax to continue to get the return yards for them, they have Maclin and DJax is becoming to valuable for the team to risk him out there. So to me it depends on your roster and where the rest of your team is. Good luck.

viewtopic.php?t=466614

[MadDog36]

Djax, can't believe i'm saying this, but he is younger and you'd have the consistent and no worries.