Favre or Smith - WHIR

[dgcesq]

Favre has gotten cold. I don't know why I draft that guy every year - he's so good to me in the regular season, then takes a big dump in the playoffs. Anyway, he's playing Chicago, so if he's going to get hot, this would be the week. Other option is Alex Smith, who's playing Detroit this week. Is this the week to bench Favre? I usually follow the rule, don't bench a stud. HELP!

QB: A. Smith Favre
RB: Forte, Addai, Bradshaw, Ganther, R. Bush, Snelling
R: Colston, Marshall, Sims-Walker, M. Austin
TE: Gonzalez
K: Crosby
DST: Green Bay

[crazysparky]

farve he will bounce back help me viewtopic.php?t=465851

[dgcesq]

I'm really leaning to Smith - it's hard not sto start any QB playing DET. In fact, I don't think any QB this year has played DET and not walked away with 200+ and a couple of scores. Plus, Frank Gore's going to have a field day, so Smith won't even be the main focus. Favre may or may not have a good day vs. CHI. He definitely has something to prove, but I don't know if I can risk another bust from my starting QB. Isn't Smith the safer play here?

[franchinboy]

I think Smith is the safer play. You should get good enough production out of him to not be pissed after his game. Favre on the other hand could go either way. I wouldnt risk it personally.


Here's mine:

http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=19&t=466049#p3177890

[Wile E Coyote]

i think smith is also the safer play
you never know at what point they might bench favre - this game means nothing

go with smith and then please help me with mine

viewtopic.php?f=19&t=465973