Should I give up Kevin Smith to get Roddy White? I like White better straight up, but I have more depth at WR versus RB... let me know what you think and leave a link!!! Thanks.
QB - Rivers*, Moore RB - CJ*, Charles*, K. Smith*, M. Morris, Forsett, D. Ward WR - A. Johnson*, Austin*, Burleson, A. Bryant, Garcon, M. Wallace, A. Gonzalez, N. Washington, Amendola TE - V. Davis* Keller
Roddy White finished top 10 in fantasy scoring and top 10 in PPR among WR's. Kevin Smith...not even close. Torn ACL and completed surgery on December 15th. You have to remember that this guy had an absolutely crazy amount of touches in college. I'm suprised he's made it this long. WR is such a volatile posistion...in my opinion it's easier to find a back that will produce off the wire than find a WR.
I assume you are talking about a trade. If so, then yes, I'd trade Smith for White. I might even be tempted to include his handcuff Morris and ask for White and some young high potential player, or draftpick, in return.
With CJ and Charles, and Forsett in reserve, it it unlikly you will start/need Smith or Morris anyway.
2011 FFB Totals Terrible at everything, and a liar.
You go with White here. You can draft rb depth new guys pop up every year. Also with Smith's injuries you have to assume the Lions won't go into next year with just Smith/Morris cause he hasn't been able to shoulder the load yet. White/Ryan will be a great combo for years to come also.
I've heard reports that Smith might not be the starting RB next year, even if he's able to get healthy before training camps. Don't want to be taking that chance especially if you'd be risking White. Gotta go with Roddy White. Ryan will bounce back next year and White will benefit
Go with Roddy, he will be good for a while. Running backs come and go quickly, so it'd be great to have 3 very solid wrs as well as CJ, Charles, and Forsett.
Cafe Home
Fantasy Baseball
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by cspirk » Mon Jan 04, 2010 2:04 pm 
