Who is the #1 rookie Rb?

[TruNinerFan]

I have the first pick in my dynasty league next week. I was pretty set on Spiller before the draft. But, after SD traded up for Matthews I am having a change of heart. I don't like the fact that Spiller will split time with Lynch and jackson, plus Buffalo is a bad team. I see Matthews getting most of the work in SD, plus the goal line carries. Who should it be CJ or Matthews? BTW, this is a NON PPR.

[DemonDeacon]

i have a man crush on Matthews. The kid has a Bo Jackson like body to him. 6 foot 220 and runs a 40 time rivaling CJ Spillers. I think matthews might be the next "Big Thing" as far as RBs go.

[spider321]

Matthews

[djadrock]

Matthews by a long shot...look where he is playing....no pressure because they are a pass first team but with his talent they should be able to use him sooner, rather than later


help: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=467140

[Indibuck]

Yeah Matthews easily...

[Cowboys 4 life]

Situation for Matthews outweighs the situation for Spiller.

I'd take Matthews

[TruNinerFan]

I took matthews. I just pray that I didn't pass up the next Chris Johnson

Thanks for the advice fellas

[haloswin2002]

I say Matthews and it isn't even close. Choosing between best and spiller is much harder...

[dblj9911]

Well living in western NY Buffalo to me is the Oakland of the east, they just have no clue. I do think Spiller could play well in a good situation, but they need a lot of o-line help, wr help, consistent qb play, other than that Buffalo has a pretty solid team. I'd take Matthews just for his offense that he is going to be surrounded with. Good luck.

[Lithioq]

Matthews