Will you help with me this trade?? (WHIR)...

[Saintsfan2004]

This post is kinda long so please bare with me.

I am in a dynasty league. We use offensive players and IDP. The scoring system goes like this.

WR: 1 point per 10 rec yards, 1 point per reception, 6 points per TD.
RB: 1 point per 10 rushing yards, 1 point per reception, 1 point per 10 recieving yards. 6 points per TD

Here is my roster as of right now: (Keep in minf this is a salary league, players who were hurt last year have low salaries and players who performed well are higher)

QB: McNabb, Sanchez, Whitehurst
RB: Reggie Bush, Tomlinson, Rashad Jennings
WR: Hines Ward, Santana Moss, Terrell Owens, Darrius Heyward Bey
TE: Shockey, Cooley
K: Vinitari

DL: Shaun Rogers, Tommie Harris, BJ Raji
DE: Peppers, Vanden Bosch, Jackson (KC)
LB: Laurentius, Vilma, Thomas Davis
CB: Charles Tillman, Champ Bailiy, Vonte Davis
S: Bob Sanders, Roy Williams

Now that all of that is out the way on to buisness.

I currently hold the #2 pick in our rookie draft. I was going to go with a RB at that pick. I assume Ryan Matthews will go #1. Which would leave me with Best or Spiller (who I am not really crazy about).

I was offered the follwoing trade for my #2 pick. I would give up Jennings, Bob Sanders and my #2 pick in exchange for Ochocinco, Darren Mcfadden, and a 3rd round pick. This trade would give me another good WR in case T.O. can't find a team and it would also give me a young RB that I want in Mcfadden. Should I pull the trigger on this trade or hold onto what I have and just draft one of thos other RBs???

Thanks in advace.

[hartmtown]

It sounds like you want 88 and McFadden, so if that's the case, it's not a terrible trade for you. But the drop from #2 to a 3rd rounder is a steep one.

Personally, I'd decline. TO should catch on somewhere, and McFadden's just too much of an unknown in the Raiders' O, although he'll be better this year with a better passing game. I'd target Best, as you said, or see what else you can get to move down but stay in the first round.

[bungle613]

It sounds like you want 88 and McFadden, so if that's the case, it's not a terrible trade for you. But the drop from #2 to a 3rd rounder is a steep one.

Personally, I'd decline. TO should catch on somewhere, and McFadden's just too much of an unknown in the Raiders' O, although he'll be better this year with a better passing game. I'd target Best, as you said, or see what else you can get to move down but stay in the first round.

This is pretty much exactly what I would say. Not a horrible deal but I think I have a good idea of what McFadden's career will be and I would rather take a shot on Best being a legit RB1.