Appeals court upholds dismissal of fan lawsuit over Patriots' taping Associated Press
PHILADELPHIA -- NFL fans miffed by the New England Patriots' secret videotaping of their opponents' signals can boycott games or team merchandise, but they can't seek legal damages, a U.S. appeals court ruled Wednesday.
The appeals panel upheld a district judge's ruling that dismissed the suit by lawyer Carl Mayer, a New York Jets season ticket holder from Princeton, N.J.
Mayer had argued that fans spent large sums to see games that essentially were rigged, and he sought $185 million in damages for Jets fans alone. The 3rd Circuit Court didn't buy it.
"We do not condone the conduct on the part of the Patriots and the team's head coach, and we likewise refrain from assessing whether the NFL's sanctions (and its alleged destruction of the videotapes themselves) were otherwise appropriate," Senior Judge Robert E. Cowen wrote for the three-judge panel.
However, Cowen said Mayer failed to prove any legal right to damages.
"At best, he possessed nothing more than a contractual right to a seat from which to watch an NFL game between the Jets and the Patriots, and this right was clearly honored," Cowen wrote.
In oral arguments in Philadelphia last month, the judges -- one a longtime Pittsburgh Steelers fan -- seemed to share Mayer's concern over the taping, peppering lawyers with questions for more than an hour. Cowen called the taping "a horrendous violation." But he also believed the league issued "a whopper" of a fine -- $750,000 -- against the Patriots and coach Bill Belichick after they were caught taping signals at the Jets' 2007 home opener in Giants Stadium.
The Patriots went on to win that game 38-14.
Mayer and his lawyer, Bruce Afran, both worked for consumer advocate Ralph Nader earlier in their careers and consider the videotaping a consumer-fraud case.
"It's a clear issue of consumer fraud," Afran said Wednesday. "The mere fact that this is in the context of football doesn't mean that the people who pay to see the game have no rights."
Rest of Article: Appeals court upholds dismissal of fan lawsuit over Patriots' taping