First, I think it is a mistake to count on much from Nicks. He is very tempting because he is very similar to Plax but can never seem to duplicate the production of Plax. The NYG have gone a different route with Smith and Manningham.
Second, I would take AJ, Marshall, and Matthews.
QB: BREES, Cutler
RB: TURNER, MCGAHEE, R. JENNINGS, Leshoure, D. Williams, Hillman, Hunter, Dwyer
WR: CRUZ, GARCON, Amendola, Edwards, D. Baldwin