Better Keeper, A.Curry or Dumervil?

[tmoney26]

1 pt tkl/ass, 3 pts sk/int, 6pts for td's, 2pts for everything else

Curry was a gigantic bust last year in IDP. Should I roll the dice on another year with him?

[mattb47]

Dumervil is pretty elite as a sack artist and 3 pts/sack is pretty solid numbers there. I'd probably keep Dumervil over Curry as Curry has a lot of competition for tackles in Seattle and was kind of a disappointment last season from a fantasy perspective.

[gridiron-guru]

Dumervil is done for the year (not sure if you are following the news closely so I thought I'd not that.)

If your points per sack were 4+ then I'd take Dumervil.
Curry has been in his system for a full year and I believe he is going to take a gigantic leap forward this year.

He has the range to be a tackling machine in Seattle, and their defense is bad enough that he will see plenty of opportunities. Curry has the potential to mix in a few interceptions...maybe even a TD or two...I'd keep Curry

[bazzy_51]

Dumervil is done for the year (not sure if you are following the news closely so I thought I'd not that.)

If your points per sack were 4+ then I'd take Dumervil.
Curry has been in his system for a full year and I believe he is going to take a gigantic leap forward this year.

He has the range to be a tackling machine in Seattle, and their defense is bad enough that he will see plenty of opportunities. Curry has the potential to mix in a few interceptions...maybe even a TD or two...I'd keep Curry

This was posted before Dumervil's injury, so I'm pretty sure if he could change his keeper pick to Curry he has done so by now. I also don't think its as easy to say that Curry is in his 2nd year and will make big jumps, I think he may record a few more tackles and a sack or two, but thats about it. Have to realize that Lofa was out all but 5 games last year and will shift back into the MLB slot, moving Herring to SLB and Curry to WLB. This could help Curry's chances to accumulate a few more sacks and an INT or 2, covering more routes then Herring will be.

Don't get me wrong Curry is a top young LB, but I think it will take some more experience and better yet, better opportunities not involving Tatupu or a breakout player in Herring for Curry to become a top end option at LB.

[anap]

Do you HAVE to keep one? Try to pickup Rolando McLain.

I'm a Seahawks fan and it doesn't look like Curry will live up to his 1st round drafting. Plus with Lofa around and the excellent and under-rated David Hawthorne, he won't come close to being a tackle machine. Hopefully I'm wrong because he is described as an athletic freak, but he doesn't have the natural instincts of a Cushing or Willis.

[TheGhost]

Curry is looking like a bust.

[anap]

Curry = Bust, confirmed.