On deck with 2nd round pick in 12 team dynasty!

[jmlevy]

12 team H2H dynasty in second year, keep 15 each season with 5 round offline draft, 6 team playoff
Roster: QB, 2 WR, 2 RB, TE, W/R/T, K, DEF, 3 D, IR, 8 BN
Scoring: default with PPR (.5 pt per recpt) and 6 pts per return TD

QB: BFavre, KKolb, MCassel, JFreeman
WR: SRice, RWhite, JMaclin, MSims-Walker, SSmith (Car)
RB: JAddai, JCharles, MForte, DBrown
TE: ODaniels
K: MCrosby
DEF: Saints

With my first round pick, I drafted Kevin Kolb due to the uncertainty surrounding Favre. Last thing I want is to rely on Cassel or Freeman as my starting QB for this (and subsequent seasons).

With that said, I am considering two positions with this next pick: RB and TE. I have already received an offer to trade JMaclin for MBarber. What are your thoughts on that deal outside of my draft pick?

Out of the players listed below, who would be your top three? Is that based on my roster, overall value, etc?

Best available RBs:
LenDale White
Willis McGahee
Toby Gerhart
Tashard Choice
Glen Coffee
Maurice Morris
James Davis
Willie Parker
Le'Ron McClain
Derrick Ward
Bernard Scott
Javon Ringer
Correll Buckhalter
Kevin Faulk
Sammy Morris
Jerious Norwood
Brandon Jackson

Best available outside RB:
Mohamed Massaquoi
Jacoby Jones
Julian Edelman
Antonio Bryant
Devin Thomas
Chaz Schilens
Golden Tate
Nate Washington
Marcedes Lewis
Todd Heap
Demetrius Williams
Joshua Cribbs
Anthony Fasano
Sam Hurd
Juaquin Iglesias
Troy Williamson
Brandon LaFell
Matt Moore
Jermaine Gresham
Jerheme Urban
Patrick Crayton
Davone Bess
Earl Bennett
Kevin Boss
Jabar Gafney
Fred Davis
Lavernues Coles
Josh Morgan
Jason Avant
Brian Hartline
Louis Murphy
Michael Jenkins

[TruNinerFan]

I would take the BPA and I think that it's Golden Tate

[jmlevy]

I would take the BPA and I think that it's Golden Tate

Over Jacoby Jones?

[FantasySportsMaven]

He isn't the BPA, but it looks to me like you need a RB with this pick, so I'd take Bernard Scott.

[srlarson]

On the trade...I would take Barber for Maclin.....

Then with this pick I take a flyer.....and take Toby Gerhart....early reports from training camp AP is still fumbling!!!!!

[jmlevy]

I decided to go with the BPA and took GTate. Thank you all for your help!

[Irish Drunk]

I would have taken Edelman or B Scott. I think you should look at backing up Daniels at TE, he's coming off a serious injury and may not be 100%. Kevin Boss would be my choice there.