Who to pick? 10th pick... dynasty league

[ThePrez]

Need some help...

My dynasty league is in its 3rd year and we do a 3 round mini draft to start each season (after dropping 3 guys prior to draft)

Finished 3rd last year, so I have the 10th pick. Its a non-serpentine format... 12 teams.

Players available in draft are... rookies, FAs from the end of last season, and all the dropped players for mini draft.

So far we have had 4 picks taken... Mathews, Best, DBryant, Spiller

Top available options left... who are your top 6? Then I know I would get one.

QBs --
Kolb
Cassel
Bradford
Tebow

WRs --
DMcCluster
Aromashodu
LNaanee
Edelman
Jacoby Jones
Demaryius Thomas
Devin Thomas
Cotchery
ABenn
MWilliams (TB)
GTate
JGaffney
CSchilens
Doucet
Heyward-Bey

RBs --
AFoster
MHardesty
BTate
Gerhart
Westbrook

TEs --
JCarlson
JGresham
Pettigrew


Standard Yahoo scoring plus 0.5 pts per catch
Standard Yahoo roster plus WR/RB flex

My roster:

QBs - Rivers, EManning, Orton

WRs - AJohnson, Colston, Maclin, ABryant, Manningham, Royal

RBs - CJohnson, APeterson, Mendenhall, PThomas, FJones

TEs - Witten

Many thanks for your top 6 options!

[ThePrez]

Anyone have a list of top 6?

Thanks!

[bungle613]

Foster
Hardesty
Kolb
Williams
Tate
McCluster

Rookie drafts are tough, you have no NFL reference to go on but this is likely how I would draft it on talent only. You don't really need anything so take BPA. I would also try and trade up 2 spots.

[ThePrez]

Foster
Hardesty
Kolb
Williams
Tate
McCluster

Rookie drafts are tough, you have no NFL reference to go on but this is likely how I would draft it on talent only. You don't really need anything so take BPA. I would also try and trade up 2 spots.

Thanks for the reply! Much appreciated!

What are your thoughts on DThomas? I know he's been hurt this preseason but hear he is going to be a beast. Thoughts?

[bungle613]

It is possible that he is legit but I can't buy into him yet. He has shown nothing since drafted and one good performance is followed by 3 bad ones. He is a hot sleeper pick right now but let him show me at least 2 decent performances in a row. Drafting right this second, I still take McCluster over him.

[Irish Drunk]

Well. Looking at your RB roster I will take your depth there into account. Here is my top 6:

A Foster (he won't last to #10)
K Kolb
McCluster
Carlson*
Devin Thomas
Demaryius Thomas

*Normally I wouldn't include a TE backup but my rationale here is that I think Carlson should have a big season and Witten didn't have that great of a season in 2009.

[ThePrez]

Well. Looking at your RB roster I will take your depth there into account. Here is my top 6:

A Foster (he won't last to #10)
K Kolb
McCluster
Carlson*
Devin Thomas
Demaryius Thomas

*Normally I wouldn't include a TE backup but my rationale here is that I think Carlson should have a big season and Witten didn't have that great of a season in 2009.

Its not that Witten didn't have a good year... he just had 2 tds. 94 catches for 1030 yds is strong... plus we get 0.5 pt per catch.

Foster and Hardesty have been taken.... 3 more picks then I'm up.