Help me pick 8 keepers please...whir

[magus]

Need to pick 8 keepers for a 1 ppr league that also scores 6 for passing td's and .25 for completions. Everything else is pretty standard. We start QB, RB, RB, WR, WR, WR, TE, and a flex Q/R/W/T along w/ K and DEF. Here's my team:

QB's: Romo, Stafford, Hasselbeck, Delhomme
RB's: AP, Turner, Caddy, K. Smith
WR's: A Johnson, D Jackson, B Marshall, Crabtree, S Rice, TO, D Henderson, J Cotchery
TE: V Shiancoe, H Miller
K: Carney
DEF: SD

Which 8 would you keep? Off the top of my head I'm thinking Romo, Stafford, AP, Turner, A Johnson, D Jackson, B Marshall and S Rice. Also, another owner wanted too look into taking a WR off of my hands, possibly in exchange for a QB. His QB's are P and E Manning and M Ryan. Thoughts? Thanks for any help. Leave a link!

[glackk]

8 keepers! Wow, you could keep an entire starting roster.

I would pick the same 8 that you have. The only one I might change is Shiancoe for Stafford, but you have enough keepers to hold onto a developing player like Stafford.

Your 5 WR keepers are super solid. Peyton for any of them besides AJ would be pretty good. You won't be starting all 5 anyway.
If it's gotta be a WR-QB 1-for-1 trade, I wouldn't trade any of those 5 for Eli or Matt Ryan. If you can somehow manage to get TO for either of those, though, you could keep him over Stafford as your 2nd QB and start him in the flex spot. Good luck.

Take a look @ mine: Greg Jennings as a keeper in the 3rd? Pick 4.

[magus]

Thanks. Do you think I should keep 5 wr's then, instead of 4? Would you keep crabtree over Stanford?

[glackk]

Thanks. Do you think I should keep 5 wr's then, instead of 4? Would you keep crabtree over Stanford?

Oops. Apparently I can't read or count to 8. I would keep Crabtree over Stafford, and look to pick up a 2nd QB earlier than usual in the draft if you don't make this trade. My trade comments are still the same, though.