Tough Decision

[Mr.8675309]

Keepers are Shonne Green, Frank Gore and Roddy White.

I have the chance to take two of the following:

Romo, Schaub, C.Johnson, Marshall, Jennings, J.Charles, J.Stewart, R.Mathews, T.Jones, Forte.

I am taking Romo so that leaves one of the other players. After I take one of the other players I don't pick again for another 22 slots so it will be fairly slim pickings. 22 slots later Pierre Garcon, Braylon Edwards, Micheal Bush, C.Williams will probably be available, or similar players. And after that I don't pick for 34 slots, so it gets thin, so I can't miss. Any help is great.

[Mr.8675309]

How you say....bump

[bazzy_51]

Gimme Romo and either Megtron or Marshall. If it were me I would go with Megtron and Marshall then worry about a QB with your 3rd overall pick. I have Marshall as the #6WR and Megatron as the #8WR and I think the drop off after Johnson @8 and DeSean Jackson @9 is worse then the drop off from Romo to what will be around with your 3rd pick.

I would believe that guys like Flacco, Cutler, Eli and Kolb will all be there at that pick. I would much rather:

Flacco or Cutler
Roddy
Marshall
Megatron
Gore
Greene

Then the WR drop that you would be looking at (something like Roddy, Marshall/Megatron and then Garcon or Edwards) by taking Romo or Schaub over a QB a couple rounds later that will only point total out 30-40 pts less then Romo.

Help me out...

viewtopic.php?t=469231

[BearsFan65]

I agree that both those WR's (Megatron and Marshall) have more relative value than Romo does. If you're hell bent on taking Romo, then I grade Calvin just a shade higher than Marshall, simply because I think it takes Miami a little while to figure out their run/pass balance. But if it's my team, I'm taking both WR's and waiting for a reasonable QB in a later round. Good luck!

[Mr.8675309]

I'm pretty sure Flacco will be gone. One of the other guys in the league loves Flacco and will take him early. What about Mathews and Megatron. Then I could see ending up with this lineup:

Eli Manning
Greene, Gore, Matthews
White, Megatron, Garcon

or

Eli
Greene, Gore, M.Bush
White, Megatron, Marshall

Which one is better?