Please Evaluate My Trade Offer..... 100% WHIR

[Fasteddy]

Is this a fair offer for both parties...

I give..
P. Manning, J.Hightower (he has Wells) and J. Cotchery

I get..
Adrian Petereson, E. Manning and N. Legedu

I have RB's of C Benson, A. Bradshaw, R. Bush
I have WR's of W Welker, S. Rice, P. Garcon, R. Williams
I would add A. Smith to Platoon/Protect for Manning.

Thanks fopr the help. leave a topic number so I can help you if needed.

[addicted]

do you get 4 or 6 pts for qb td's?
i say no if 6 and maybe if 4. your downgrading your qb and upgrading your rb.benson and bradshaw are a decent tandem to have. bradshaw should have a good year and dip into jacobs production. nyg offense looks to predicable for defenses when they bring him in inside the 5 these days

viewtopic.php?t=469756

[BearsFan65]

Assuming standard format, I make this deal. You get a huge step up at RB, and the dropoff from one Manning to the next isn't as big as the upgrade. Your WR depth is a little suspect, so I'd reconsider dropping a player to pick up a backup QB. You can do that as needed as the season progresses. Good luck!

[Fasteddy]

I would be dropping another player not mentioned to get A. Smith to backup E. Manning. It would not affect the WR's that I have other than giving Cothery and getting Negedu (who I think will be awesome).

[BearsFan65]

Then I'd say go for it....but get your awesome guy's name right....Legedu Naanee. He'll appreciate that you got it right!

[Reg]

you are getting the best player by far, who is a lot more valuable than peyton. I'd do it

viewtopic.php?t=469776

[AngryLionsFAn]

I would go for it. There's no question that AP is a huge upgrade at RB. You can get by with Eli and A.Smith.

Help with mine?

viewtopic.php?t=469803

[srlarson]

If he proposed take the deal...but if you are proposing....guessing he will say no chance......Would take more to get the #2 player in FFL off his team.