R. Wayne vs C. Johnson

[Stelly]

In a non-ppr league, who do you like better this year, and why?

Reggie Wayne or Calvin Johnson?

Thanks, and leave a link!

[TheMax]

Calvin has way more upside and could potentially be the top WR if Stafford can just get the ball near him. Wayne is clearly the safer pick, but that's no fun. Calvin still had nearly 1000 yards in 13 games last season, which has to be his absolute floor though. I'd go with Calvin (just like I did in my draft), but I might be a little biased...

[ShaqAttaq13]

Calvin has way more upside and could potentially be the top WR if Stafford can just get the ball near him. Wayne is clearly the safer pick, but that's no fun. Calvin still had nearly 1000 yards in 13 games last season, which has to be his absolute floor though. I'd go with Calvin (just like I did in my draft), but I might be a little biased...

I agree, and also check Wayne's stats from games 12-17 last year. Excluding one big game, he had 1 touchdown and a high of 48 yards.

I don't know if hes necessarily slowing down, but Peytons got a lot of options nowadays. Also, theres a decent chance the Colts arnt gonna be playing their starts in your championship week, if you want to look to the future.

I'd take Calvin's upside.

[B3N1ZJAM1N]

gotta go with CJ mainly for the reasons stated above.