Drew Brees & MSW for Rodgers & Floyd?

[Rizzo10]

I have been offered Drew Brees and Sims-Walker for Aaron Rodgers & Malcolm Floyd... below is my roster, should I make the trade?

QB - Aaron Rodgers
RB - Frank Gore
RB - Shonn Greene
WR - Dwayne Bowe
WR - T.J. Housh
WR - Malcom Floyd
TE - Kellen Winslow
FLEX - Steve Breaston
DST - New Orleans
K - Shayne Graham
Bench - Laurence Maroney
Bench - Ben Tate
Bench - Dez Bryant
Bench - Montario Hardesty
Bench - Ladanian Tomlinson
Bench - Carson Palmer

[B3N1ZJAM1N]

Take it. I like Bree's better than Rodgers. I might be all alone on that but look at the ring(I know it wasn't just Brees) Walker is substantially better than floyd. I don't really see a risk here so If it was me I would take it.

[TheMax]

I'd stay put on this one. I like Rodgers more than Brees (I expect similar stats to last season), and I'm actually pretty high on Floyd this season. I'd say Brees and Rodgers are pretty comparable, but with an edge to Aaron, and Floyd and MSW are comparable with an edge to Floyd. I definitely wouldn't pull the trigger on this.

[d68money]

i'm on the fence on this one maybe slightly leaning Rodgers/Floyd. i think brees and rodgers are pretty much equal. floyd could become vincent jackson-esque. msw had some consistency and injury issues but he's still the best WR they have. so i think it comes down to, who do you value more.

[DaShiz23]

i'm on the fence on this one maybe slightly leaning Rodgers/Floyd. i think brees and rodgers are pretty much equal. floyd could become vincent jackson-esque. msw had some consistency and injury issues but he's still the best WR they have. so i think it comes down to, who do you value more.

I agree. MSW is on an offense that should struggle, so I think his ceiling is lower than Floyd's.



BTW, I love the Ndukwe sig!

Help?
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=469584