Should I propose this trade [WHIR 100%]

[djadrock]

I am in a 10 team PPR Dynasty league. The other owner is interested in Ronnie Brown. Should I offer him this trade?

I give up: Brown & Breaston
I get: Bradshaw & Collie

It is the best I can do with what he has.

My current thoughts are: Brown is a great back but injury prone. Breaston has Leinhart throwing to him. Bradshaw will be the RB for NYG. Collie should be a really good PPR guy.

100% WHIR

[DaShiz23]

I like this deal for you, especialliy if Bradshaw gets the bulk of the carries in NY.

Help?
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=469584

[B3N1ZJAM1N]

I think this would be a great deal, go for it

[rockchalk]

I don't like it. I'd rather have the sure #1 RB in Brown and Breaston could very well out perform Collie this year with Gonzalez back steal targets.

Help?

viewtopic.php?t=469878

[TheMax]

No way I'm doing this. Yes, Ronnie is injury prone, but when he plays, he is good. Bradshaw is still splitting carries with Jacobs regardless of what you hear in the preseason. Yes, Breaston has Leinart throwing to him, but Collie still has to compete with Wayne, Garcon, Clark and Gonzalez for looks. I like Ronnie better than Bradshaw by a lot and Breaston over Collie by a bit. No.

[Rookie06]

I would say no...Collie is not #2 on Indy he is 3.5 (wayne, clark, garcon ties with collie). Manning and Brees have the great talent of spreading the ball around. Breaston is #2 in arizona even though a medicore wr.