Normally I'd say it's a toss-up... but Rodgers gets the rushing TD's and it helps his value tremendously. 25% of the Packers rushing TD's last year were from Rogers himself.
Make the trade.
2010 12-team .5PPR
QB - Ryan, Vick
RB - S. Greene, Forte, Stewart, F. Jones, Sproles
WR - Moss, Megatron, NYG Smith, Floyd, M. Williams (TB)
TE - Cooley
D - CIN (week to week)
K - Bironas