Rate my draft - I'll rate yours!

[joejccva]

I have done 2 drafts, both are money leagues. One draft I picked 1st, and the other I picked 4th. Please rate and critique my picks in both drafts and I will return the favor.

FIRST DRAFT (Picked 1st):
QB: Kevin Kolb
HB: Chris Johnson
HB: Shonn Greene
WR: Miles Austin
WR: Chad Ochocinco
FLEX: Ahmad Bradshaw
TE: Vernon Davis
K: Ryan Longwell
DST: 49ers

BENCH: Ahmad Bradshaw(RB), CJ Spiller(RB), Tim Hightower(RB), Chad Henne(QB), Johnny Knox(WR), Heath Miller(TE)


SECOND DRAFT (Picked 4th):
QB: Matt Schaub
HB: Ray Rice
HB: Deangelo Williams
WR: Miles Austin
WR: Hines Ward
FLEX: Jahvid Best
TE: Jermichael Finley
K: Ryan Longwell
DST: Saints

BENCH: CJ Spiller(RB), Terrell Owens(WR), Dez Bryant(WR), Donald Brown(RB), Kevin Walter(WR), Carson Palmer(QB), Fred Jackson(RB was on autopick)



What do you guys think? Please rate both rosters. Thanks! WHIR!

[joejccva]

Anyone?

[Lucky7]

Really nice job in both drafts. No weaknesses except perhaps at qb with kolb. I'm not too high on him nor henne. Kolb has a nice schedule and weapons so hopefully he will pan out. Love cj and Greene with spiller. Very nice.

[B3N1ZJAM1N]

Kolb should be fine but I don't see Henne doing much if Kolb doesn't pan out. Your RB's are pretty solid so I wouldn't worry about them. I'm not a big fan of ocho this year and who really knows how know will do. Pretty good team

[wakejitsu]

Both are pretty solid. I agree on the 1st. Not sold on Kolb yet as a starter. And I predict in a couple of weeks you'll be starting Knox over Ocho.

2nd team is stronger overall.

Please take a look at mine:
viewtopic.php?t=470956

[BottomLines]

Wow, both look pretty solid. Was this a 10 or 12 team league? I really like your RB situations on both teams. I'm betting on Kolb too for one of my teams. Wanted Flaco, but he was picked ONE PICK before I got to him. Please help with mine:

viewtopic.php?t=471129

[thebrewz23]

I would agree you have 2 pretty good teams. QB on team 1 is your weakest spot. It's still hard to tell what type of year Kolb is going to have. If I were you I'd start looking at other teams in your league that have quality QBs with servicable back-up QBs and start to consider what you might be able to trade to get a #1 QB if Kolb ends up being terrible.

http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=471134