Boldin/Forte/Manningham for Jennings/JStewert/VJ? WHIR!

[619ers]

Standard scoring league with 1PPR, 12 team league WHIR! Sorry for the long post but WHIR and Ill read through yours too =)

I am being offered this trade:
Id give up - Boldin Forte and Manningham(he might want Cotchery instead of Manningham)
Id receive - GJennings JStewert and VJ or Holmes

Am I losing too much here at rb or on any part of this? Any other suggestions on a possible counter-trade offer by me?

WHIR - here is my current and his current roster(plyrs on the right side of the"///")

qb palmer///rodgers
wr a johnson, djax, boldin///jennings, ward, kwalter
rb mendenhall, forte///kmoreno, jstewert
te t gonz///witten
k prater///crosby
def minn///new orleans
BN cotchery, lee evans, manningham///vj, holmes, garrard, merc lewis
laur robinson, LMcCoy, Cadillac, flacco/// scobee, sproles, MIA Def

Should I even think about making this move or some version of it or should I stick with what I have? It's enticing me because I could upgrade at WR and Im being hopeful that VJ gets traded and plays this season!!..but I might take a hit at RB? Help me out Ill definitely help with yours!!! WHIR!!!

[kingmike74]

PPR......No, no and no.

This guy is on the Forte wagon and wants a piece of it. If you think Forte will pull an '09 out of his at, by all means do the deal, but I think Forte is going to be good in a PPR, and about 50 FP better than Stewie. Jennings and Boldin are a wash.


If you get time, take a look at my post
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=471096

[619ers]

Thanks for the help!

Anyone else care to share their thoughts and have input on this situation?? WHIR!!! Thanks!

[Moose484848]

I kinda like Stewart more than Forte.. significantly actually. Is it a keeper league?

I think Jennings and Boldin are about equal but personally I like Boldin better and don't think he gets hurt as much as Jennings.

I think Vjax could be a steal if he eventually signs or gets traded and I think Manny is OK, but nowhere near the upside to VJAX

If it was me, I would probably do it after much consideration LOL

Thanks for helping on mine...

[JoshKnows46]

boldon and jennings are about even, but i prefer boldon...gb has so many options, and i think finly gonna take a large portion of the tds.

i would absolutly not trade forte for stewert in ppr, deangelo is the much better back, and as long as he stays healthy he's gonna get the bulk of the carrers, and forte will have a huge year in ppr, mike martz's offense will make forte ppr gold.


can you check out mine, and tell me what you think?
http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=471147

[JoshKnows46]

already did lol..thanks for the help, but maroney is worthless, they talking about him not even making the team right now, what other rb or wr should i try for....he already tryed offering me vernon davis/maroney for mccluster/spiller but i declined...i was tryed to get vernon davis a san fran d, but he wasn't having it.

[619ers]

Thanks Moose and Josh! Im still a little torn on this..anyone else got any thoughts?

[JoshKnows46]

it all depends on if you think mike marts offense will work in chicago, if you do, forte will benifit greatly from it...and if you believe in j.stewert, dwilliams was on his way to a huge season last year if it wasn't for him getting hurt, i personally belive jstewert is slightly overrated when he's compared to d.williams.

[ZeroPointZero]

The Flacco-Boldin connection is going to take you to the championship this year. You heard it here first. I would not make that trade.
The big problem on your end of the trade is the Chicago O-line (terrible). But the bigger problems on his end are Rodgers' many, many targets, Stewie doesn't get enough touches, and VJ is talking about being OK with sitting out the entire season. You're basically giving up two starters and a bench player for one starter and two bench.

[619ers]

Thanks yall! I guess its settled..Ill stick with them..now you got me thinkin about my QB spot though..Now I might have to ask yall in another post who to start at QB!! Haha Thanks again for all the input