Favre or Eli Manning week 1?

[ajmetallica]

Which one would you start week 1

Favre @ NO

or

Eli Manning vs. CAR

Please help. Thanks.

[bisklimpkit]

I'd start Favre because of the high probability of this game turning into a shooting match.

[David592207]

Favre is still Favre, bad ankle and all. He will get his points and has something to prove against the team that knocked him out of the playoffs. On the other hand, Eli has looked strictly average at best so far.

[archie814]

I have the same two QB's on one of my teams, and I never even thought about putting in Eli. Unless Favre proves to me that he's not a top QB, he's gonna be in there. He was 5th in scoring last year in my league, if he's there again I'll be stoked. You should start Favre.

[rufio657]

tough call bc favres #1 receiver is out.. might be a shooting match.. eli is probable safe.. depends if you will need a monster week or avg points will do..

[ajmetallica]

bump