Thomas or Naanee WHIR

[Scooter85]

I have devin thomas and I have been hearing he'll probably make the team but wont do much so should I cut him to pick up Naanee because I hear a lot of good things about him

[snixx79]

Thomas has more upside...but hasnt been able to beat out Joey Galloway. How much of that is inability and how much is Shanahan trying to motivate the kid...? I dont know. I dont think Nanee has as much potential with Gates and Floyd in the mix, not to mention i think SD runs more with Matthews at the helm. However, i also think Nanee's floor is higher. Will he outproduce Thomas this year? Very likley unless Thomas shows something to win the outside job. I dont think you can be faulted for dropping Devin for Nanee....but i might think differently ina keeper/dynasty.


Mine?


viewforum.php?

[JRM4833]

I think Naanee is looking like a solid pick this year. Thomas hasn't shown me enough yet to convince me that he'll have much value this year (looking forward may be a different question).

Please help: viewtopic.php?t=471293