McCluster or Huggins? WHIR

[BearsFan65]

12 team PPR league, start QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE, D/ST, K. My roster:

QB - E Manning
RB - ADP, R Mathews, A Foster
WR - R White, D Bowe, M Floyd, J Gaffney, Jac Jones, D McCluster
TE - Z Miller
DEF - NYJets
K - D Carpenter

McCluster was my last draft pick before the kicker, the shot in the dark kind of upside pick that you take at the end. Looking over the roster, I wonder if I'm not better off dropping McCluster for Kareem Huggins. It's unlikely I ever start McCluster unless Bowe gets hurt and McCluster goes crazy, and Huggins is one Cadillac Williams knee tweak away from being a feature back, admittedly in a not very good offense.

The other possible better use of the roster spot is for Big Ben, who went undrafted and now will only be out 4 weeks. Who's the right guy to have on my roster? WHIR, thanks!

[HskrPwr13]

You're correct regarding McCluster. Drop him for Ben. Thats where your need is.

[zechs]

you need big ben asap; he's your QB1 when he's back

mccluster for big ben is an easy call

[DemonDeacon]

i agree with the others. drop mccluster for big ben. i like huggins but i dont think hes worth a roster spot unless your in a super deep league or a dynasty

[Mr.Joshua]

Huggins is the type of guy I like to stash and see if he gets a shot, Caddy isn't the poster child for health. Personally, I think Manning will be top 10 again, so unless you start 2 qb's, I go with Huggins.

[Shark1225]

I go grab Big Ben. I agree with you on the McCluster/Huggins situation. I think McCluster is the better player and will likely put up more fantasy points the problem is he is unlikely to get enough of them to warrant a start in any week, Huggins on the other hand is one injury away from being a RB2 and at a position which is the most injury prone.

[kingmike74]

Well, I like both this year, but one is not starting right now, and that guy is Huggins. McCluster will be used more than people think and I am telling you this, McCluster will be Percy v.2 this year, all aboard!!!


And yeh, use the extra space for the rapist.

[FantasyFanatic]

I would not even pause....Big Ben; no brainer. I am big on Huggins and have been watching him closely for the last couple of weeks; but I am starting to cool down a little. TB's head coach was talking earlier this week and kept referring to Graham; I don't know if Huggins' shot is as straight of a path as a lot of people think.