Many thanks for your help with mine ealier today.
Best player(s) swing(s) the deal, and in this case Schaub and SJax clearly outweigh White and Davis.
I play a lot of 2QB and PPR, in fact I have Brees and Schaub in my favorite league this season.
With Rodgers and Schaub you'd have two top 5 QB's. Unless someone in your league has two of Brees/Manning/Brady on their roster, you'll have a huge weekly advantage at QB. If either Rodgers or Schaub get hurt you still have a top 5 QB to carry the load. Good as he looked at the end of last season, no way Young gives you that kind of production/advantage.
SJax is clearly a risk, but as long as he's on the field he's a potential top 5 RB, especially with .5pt ppr. Matthews is a complete unknown outside of a couple pre-season games and strong college production. Yes, he's looked good, and brother the hype machine has been working overtime all summer. But do any of us truly know what he's going to look like in the 4th quarter several games into the seaon? I don't completely trust SJax, but there's no denying it, he's a MAN and a "football player". At this point I don't think there's any comparison.
I'd truly hate to lose Roddy, in ppr he's pure gold. You know you're getting 90+ catches and the potential for a dozen TDs.
But with Harvin you get his WR production, which is bound to grow this season, and you also get his direct snap rushing yards. If you got Kick return yards it'd be a lock. Sure he's a risk, but his upside huge.
I see Davis and Celek as a push. If it's my team, I try to take the WRs out of the deal... otherwise I'd make this trade and not look back. Good Luck!
Surf, Ski, Drink Red Wine - Everyone will wonder why you're grinning! Go Broncos!