Pick 2: Floyd, Wallace, Cribbs (return yards)

[default01]

Right now, I've got Floyd & Wallace in as starters but I think Cribbs might be a better choice because of the return yardage. How would you rank those 3 players? Settings and my team are below.

12 team league
Pass/Return Yards = 25 yds/pt
Rush/Rec Yards = 10 yds/pt
Pass TDs = 4 pts
Rush/Rec/Return TDs = 6 pts

QB: P. Manning
RB: S. Jackson
RB: J. Charles
WR: M. Floyd
WR: M. Wallace
W/R: A. Foster
W/R: M. Forte
TE: J. Finley
D/ST: Cincinnati
K:

BN: L. Tomlinson
BN: D. Sproles
BN: D. Aromashodu
BN: J. Jones (HOU)
BN: J. Cribbs
BN: J. Gaffney
BN: M. Williams (TB)

I still need to pick up a kicker and am leaning toward dropping Gaffney.

I also will probably switch out my D/ST:
Cincinnati @NE
Tennessee vs Oak
Tampa Bay vs Cle
Arizona @ StL

[Uncle Boz]

I like Cribbs. I have him in a return yards league as well.

I heard rumor that he will get less return touches, but we'll see. Start him over Wallace.

Also, Percy Harvin is a beast in these types of leagues. Not sure how savy your league is, but acquiring him would be huge.

viewtopic.php?f=19&t=471825#p3218624

[Uncle Boz]

McCluster is another guy to keep an eye on, as well as Devin Thomas. They both seem to be involved in the offense and the return game.

[cnewby]

Thanks for the help on mine. I would say to start Cribbs over Wallace, especially in ppr format. Cle knows that Cribbs has to touch the ball to be successful and imo Wallace is solely a home run hitter.

[jackbrown53]

I would say Cribbs as well. The potential for over 100 return yards is greater than the potential for Wallace to be over 100 yds receiveing.

[archie814]

With those return yards incentives Cribbs is a great play. As a Browns fan, I can tell you he can take it to the house everytime he touches it. It's sick. I'd play Floyd and Cribbs. Plus, he's becoming a bigger role in the offense.

http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=19&t=471936

[pacoweaz]

thanks for help on mine. I'll echo others and say Cribbs over Wallace as well. the return yards put him over the top there.

[vrOOm]

1. Floyd
2. Cribbs
3. Wallace

Don't drop Gaffney!!!

Please help with mine:
viewtopic.php?f=19&t=472061

[tHe.pRoFessionaL]

I am going to go against the grain and say Floyd and Aromashodu....very close b/w him and Cribbs though.

[default01]

Thanks for the help. I'm going with Floyd and Cribbs.

As for Aromashodu, you may be right but I think he's a riskier play. I'm more comfortable with him on my bench week 1 as a potential break-out candidate.

As for not dropping Gaffney, who would you rather drop? Gaffney, Williams (TB), Jones (Hou)?

I waited late to take my first WR and stocked up on potential, but I have to choose one to drop now and I really think Gaffney is the odd man out. I've been going through teams in my league trying to think of possible 2-for-1's but haven't been able to come up with something I'd be happy with so I really think I just have to let one of them go.