Chris Johnson for McCoy and Fred Jackson? Fair/Unfair?

[kswiss]

I'm in a $$ league where the Commissioner is making a trade to get Chris Johnson. The person with Chris Johnson (a man in his late 20's-early 30's, who refs lacrosse games, and follows sports), has no idea what he's doing and I feel the Commissioner is taking advantage of him. The Commissioner also is the only one who can veto a trade.

Before I really start freaking out, I'd like to get other opinions on the trade to maybe temper my reaction. On a scale of 1 to 10, how balanced is the trade? (1 being balanced, 10 being very unbalanced). Is it a little unbalanced, or very unbalanced.

The Trade is Chris Johnson, Dexter McCluster, Leodis McKelvin(IDP) for LeSean McCoy, Fred Jackson, Jared Allen.

It's a 10 person traditional scoring league, we only have 5 bench spots, so good players are commonly on the WW.

Team A:
QB: Donavan McNabb
WR: Dwyane Bowe, Mike Sims-Walker
RB: Chris Johnson, Rashard Mendenhall
TE: Tony Gonzalez
Flex: Shonne Greene
K: Nate Keading
Def: NY Giants
IDP: Leodis McKelvin, Shawntae Spencer
Bench: Vince Young, Dexter McCluster, Sidney Rice

Commish's Team:
QB: Jay Cutler
WR: Randy Moss, Larry Fitzgerald
RB: Adrian Peterson, LeSean McCoy
TE: Visanthe Shianco
Flex: Percy Harvin
K: Steven Gostkowski
Def: New Orleans
IDP: Patrick Willis, Jon Beason
Bench: Matt Forte, Fred Jackson, Robert Meachem, Jared Allen

[runningchoc]

I'd be raising HELL right now. That's a ridiculous trade. If the "victim" indeed doesn't know what he's doing, the commish should show a little more responsibility in this situation and not manipulate inexperienced members out of their best players.

The trade is definitely in the 9-10 range for unfairness, especially if the Johnson owner is a rookie FF player.

[JoshKnows46]

1-10 scale, thats a 20, i'd quit that league.

[B3N1ZJAM1N]

Hahahaha ya thats some BS

[wolfbear702]

whoop his ass then raise hell!!!!!!!!


please help me

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=471877

[xfactor0707]

RAISE HELLLL IN THAT BIATCH!!!!!!!!!!

[eagles4lyf82]

convince everyone in your league to threaten that scum of a commish that you'll unload your rosters and quit! thats just crazy and how did you end up wit a commish like that! MUTINY!!!!!!

[abercrombie9701]

Thats a very unbalanced trade.how does he hve the stones to offer a trade like that









Help me if you can
viewtopic.php?t=471909

[biggest daddy]

Bad trade . . . even without deep knowledge why would the other coach consider this? what does he have to gain?

Only if your commish offered AP then it would be more evenly balanced.

Now you can use this thread to support your case.

[kswiss]

Thanks everyone for letting me know I'm not crazy. The Commissioner just pushed the trade through this afternoon, after it only was proposed last night. Only three people including myself responded, two of us vetoed and the other one said 'If he gets screwed, its with his eyes open'. Now I just have to try and get my money back, because I just want out of this league.